Israeli Forces Render Healthcare Inaccessible When it is Needed The Most

Military incursions by Israeli forces in the West Bank are increasing in violence and frequency since the beginning of the war in Gaza in October 2023. Medical and paramedical staff are repeatedly attacked, harassed, blocked and hindered as they attempt to care for the wounded. Between May 21 and 23, 2024, Jenin City and its refugee camp endured a 42-hour military incursion, one of the latest and longest in a pattern of brutal raids.

This incursion started at 8 AM, while children arrived at school and people went to work. One of the first victims was Dr Jabarin, a surgeon who was shot in the back and killed while walking to work at Khalil Suleiman Hospital. He arrived on a stretcher instead, and his colleagues had to carry the extra burden of his loss throughout the incursion. In total, Israeli forces killed twelve Palestinians during this raid.

Incursions in Jenin are becoming more frequent and highly unpredictable, lasting from hours to days. They are primarily focused on Jenin Camp, which houses over 23,000 Palestinian refugees. Snipers are deployed around the camp and city. Military forces in large, armoured vehicles block the roads and hinder access to ambulances. It can take hours for people to reach the Khalil Suleiman Hospital, which is normally a two-minute walk from the entrance of Jenin Camp. As the road to the hospital might be a death trap, many choose to stay at home with injuries and conditions which they would otherwise seek acute medical care for.

In most MSF projects, we mitigate a gap in healthcare. Here, healthcare is available down the road, but when it is needed the most, it is deliberately made inaccessible. During incursions in Jenin and Tulkarem, we have witnessed a pattern of continued and systematic attacks on healthcare workers and blockages of ambulances. Every single paramedic I have spoken to has explained situations where they have been personally harassed, physically assaulted and hindered while trying to provide emergency medical care. Several have been threatened, detained, physically assaulted, and some even shot at.

In Jenin, we conduct capacity building for doctors and nurses in the emergency department of Khalil Suleiman Hospital. In Tulkarem, we do the same at Thabet Thabet Hospital. However, as the patients are blocked from reaching the hospitals on time, we also train ambulance workers and medical and paramedical volunteers in the camps. We aim to enable them to keep injured people alive longer.

We had to develop a whole new approach to establish measures beyond immediate lifesaving so that patients might hold onto life until they can safely access adequate care. We have also equipped stabilisation points, simple rooms with a couple of beds and essential medical supplies in the camps of Jenin and Tulkarem. But as these stabilisation points have been attacked and vandalised by Israeli forces during their raids, some medical volunteers no longer feel safe working there. Hence, we moved to giving portable medical kits to volunteers.

Additionally, we initiated “stop the bleed” trainings in the camps, teaching non-medical residents how to care for wounds and apply a tourniquet. During these trainings, we have been asked by housewives, matter-of-factly, whether the bullet needs to be removed before applying pressure or how long an arm can be tourniqueted before you risk amputation. These questions tell a lot about the alarming reality in Jenin and Tulkarem, where the blockage of access to healthcare has become part of daily life that people are forced to endure.

Incursions also bring massive destruction. Houses are bombed or demolished, streets get torn up, water and sanitation systems are ripped apart, and electricity is cut. We have donated two tuk-tuks, the size of small golf carts, repurposed to function as mini ambulances inside Jenin Camp. These lifesaving tuk-tuks run on batteries. Therefore, volunteers must ration their use as they never know how long a raid might last and when they can charge it again.  We cannot add a generator or solar panels to the setup, as this would merely create another target.

Despite constant harassment and fear for their own lives, volunteer paramedics continue to work and tend to the wounded. Mohammed, one of the volunteers in Jenin Camp, told me how he was hit in the wrist by a sniper during the first hour of the latest incursion. He was able to get to the hospital, got patched up, and went right back to work. Some volunteers have expressed that they feel safer when they don’t wear their paramedic vests. What they are facing is a blatant disregard for the medical mission and human life. We never thought that medical vests were bulletproof, but they should certainly not be targets.  

During another recent incursion, in Nur Shams camp in Tulkarem, a Palestinian Red Crescent Society paramedic volunteer trained by MSF was shot in the leg while he was running towards a patient. He was wearing his vest, clearly indicating his medical status. It took more than seven hours before he was allowed to reach the hospital and get the care he needed. Fortunately, he survived. When we asked him if he had a message to the world, he said that he didn’t because no one was listening anyway. Here, people feel that they are not seen, not significant, not worthy of attention, and abandoned by the world.

While the funeral of Dr Jabarin was about to take place, I asked Dr Abu Baker, the director of Khalil Suleiman Hospital, what we, as MSF, could do to help improve their situation. ‘The most important thing you can do’, he said, ‘is let the world know what is happening here.’